I don't get why if you are different than Smogon, then you are horrible at everything. I mean, this is PC, not Smogon, I don't see why I have to march in their lines and bow at their feet.
Pinsir has lower HP and SDef. And also lacks the power of Megahorn. Other than that, not much of a difference, but people would rather prefer Heracross instead of Pinsir.
It has decent stats and a large movepool. As a sweeper it's outclassed by Medicham, but it has huge supporting capabilities. Thunder Wave, Will-o-Wisp and Hypnosis are all extremely useful status moves and few others can learn all those moves. Of course Gallade's HP and Defense aren't the best, but it can withstand at least one reasonably strong special Attack with its high Special Defense. Its Speed is no issue after your opponent is paralyzed. Gallade is extremely useful as long as you can predict your opponent's moves. The reason why most people think Gallade is bad is because they try to make it a Medicham copy, which obviously just won't work for it.
And you should stop mini-modding. Last time I checked, that post was off-topic so you have no right to tell others to be off-topic. And last time I checked, Anti-Pop Culture Warrior 13's post actually expressed his opinion on the tiers whereas yours was just plain midi-modding.
I partly agree with you. Tyranitar would get creamed in ubers, but some of your arguments are flawed. First of all, Ghost moves are not very effective on Dark so how would a Ghost move take down Tyranitar? Second, Tyranitar can easily withstand one or two Ground or Water moves and either set up a sweep or continue sweeping after taking the hit. Third, Tyranitar is not a wall, it's a tank/sweeper. And finally, any Sandstream team will have something to counter the obvious Tyranitar counters.
