Graphic Rating Thread

[Chikara]

Relyt - This is the first banner from you I've seen like this :o
It's got a nice texture to it, the coloring is really cool looking. I like the text part if it most of all. I can't tell if it's a brush or you typed that. Either way, it's awesome 9/10

No one rated mine because I was being helpful and rating theirs ;;

And I made this one a few minutes ago

 

[Live in Color]

In the top one the render blends so well with the background, very nice. :D

The bottom one looks good too and is that Visitor BRK font? Anyways 9/10 for both. ^^

 

[Nytkoi]

Relyt - This is the first banner from you I've seen like this :o
It's got a nice texture to it, the coloring is really cool looking. I like the text part if it most of all. I can't tell if it's a brush or you typed that. Either way, it's awesome 9/10

No one rated mine because I was being helpful and rating theirs ;;

And I made this one a few minutes ago

you're not allowed to post an image on 1 page >< and They're pretty good.

 

[Loki]

Mizt; Unfortunately, that was Spam, as not only did you mini-mod, you gave her the wrong information. And to add to that, you broke the commenting rule to boot.

So this will be your third warning.

Chikara; What Mizt meant was that you can't repost the same banner on the same page. It's kind of like bumping.

However, let me clarify that that was because that's 'bumping'. Because Chikara added another banner to be rated, it's fine. If she simply posted that single banner, then it would've been bumping.

I'll explain this rule in more depth when we restart this thread.

And thus, I ask again;

What do you guys think of restarting this thread? (Yes, I've taken your opinion in stride already evilcheese.)

 

[Live in Color]

Okay, I made a few changes to the banner I posted before.

I really like it, could you guys rate it please?

 

[Zebra Thunderhead]

Just a quick question before I rate/post stuff; am I allowed to post icons here or is it strictly tags? :x

 

[Loki]

You're allowed to post icons. ^^

Although, the reception for icons seems to be rather undercooked, as far as my experience goes. xD

 

[evilcheese]

@Relyt - the animation is cool. even with the text its still kind of empty. a resize would be good.

please rate

 

[Momoko]

@evilcheese-it looks nice but again the text looks sorta..standoutish-try lowering the opacity more, other than that it's good and i like how gengar blends it :D 8.5/10..oh and for ur heracross one, it looks so-well it's blended nicely but wha'ts the use of the lighting? and again ur text sticks out like a chocolate bar at fat camp, but it matched with heracross,soo--8.5/10 again.

@Relyt-wow pure genius, i really like it, the only thing that sorta puts me off is the huge amount of text thats put into text so small u cant read it (which lots of ppl seem to be doing now >.< well anyways i like it...9/10

@chikara-well, the first one doesn't blend it very well, but in this case it doesn't relee hav to--7/10

for ur second one, it looks rather..plain but stil it's nice to look at..8/10



ANF FOR THE 3RD TIME ID LIKE TO GET MY CURRENT SIG RATED--_--

 

[Live in Color]

@Relyt-wow pure genius, i really like it, the only thing that sorta puts me off is the huge amount of text thats put into text so small u cant read it (which lots of ppl seem to be doing now >.< well anyways i like it...9/10



ANF FOR THE 3RD TIME ID LIKE TO GET MY CURRENT SIG RATED--_--

Thanks! ^^, yeah I wanted to do all of the little text. I could tell you what the top part means, but it's a secret. And the bottom part was actually a brush!

I rated your current signature already. :P

I'm also just wondering, there is a render thread, but it does not say in that thread that it is for ratings. So if we wanted to get a render rated would we post it here or in the other thread?

 

[Momoko]

hokay, first, graphix r things u make with a program, adding a background effex etc. and second y wuld u want one rated O.o a render is a render- their all random and just a picture...well render but still..hope i answered ur question...i haven't seen ur rating :/

And ill do another RANDOM rating--histugaya- that's relee gud for ur first try! My gosh it's so cool well at least better than my first- i would origiinally give u a 4/10 but since it's ur first 9.5/10

 

[Live in Color]

hokay, first, graphix r things u make with a program, adding a background effex etc. and second y wuld u want one rated O.o a render is a render- their all random and just a picture...well render but still..hope i answered ur question...i haven't seen ur rating :/

And ill do another RANDOM rating--histugaya- that's relee gud for ur first try! My gosh it's so cool well at least better than my first- i would origiinally give u a 4/10 but since it's ur first 9.5/10

I think I posted it in the rate the signature thread.

Anyway, I thought that a render could be rated depending on how clean it was rendered and such.

 

[Momoko]

Possible,but a render is a render-and like i said above it's just a random pic with no effects..and my histugaya rating wasn't for u it was for the person above,histugaya O.o

oh and mizt i no ur banner, but what the hey..it's good but i think somewhat small for a banner. Nothing really makes it stand out but i no ur still just beggining so..7.5/10 i liked some of ur other ones better

 

[Loki]

Um, no Sasuke_Darkness, please don't answer questions when you don't know the actual answer.

Relyt, it's fine if you post a render here. You were right, you can rate a render based on cleanliness and quality, so go ahead and post it here, because there's no where else to post it. The text in your banner is incredibly creative! That's an awesome idea! It would've been better if you'd moved it more to the right though, but the effects on the text are nice, and it fits well. If you moved the text centered a little more between the left edge and Nova, it'd be a really nice banner.

Also, I'm thinking of a new concept for the graphics rating thread. Would you guys like to do it the way it was in the beginning of this thread, where it was sort of like 'the one above' or the rating threads in Fun Time? Where you have to rate the banner posted above you? That way, we wouldn't have to deal with this whole, "RATE MY BANNER PLZ" issue. And if you wanted to rate a different banner from the one above, then you'd still have to rate the one above anyway?

If nobody responds, then I'm just going to go ahead and close this thread, make a new one, and implement the idea I just mentioned. xD;

 

[Live in Color]

Um, no Sasuke_Darkness, please don't answer questions when you don't know the actual answer.

Relyt, it's fine if you post a render here. You were right, you can rate a render based on cleanliness and quality, so go ahead and post it here, because there's no where else to post it. The text in your banner is incredibly creative! That's an awesome idea! It would've been better if you'd moved it more to the right though, but the effects on the text are nice, and it fits well. If you moved the text centered a little more between the left edge and Nova, it'd be a really nice banner.

Also, I'm thinking of a new concept for the graphics rating thread. Would you guys like to do it the way it was in the beginning of this thread, where it was sort of like 'the one above' or the rating threads in Fun Time? Where you have to rate the banner posted above you? That way, we wouldn't have to deal with this whole, "RATE MY BANNER PLZ" issue. And if you wanted to rate a different banner from the one above, then you'd still have to rate the one above anyway?

If nobody responds, then I'm just going to go ahead and close this thread, make a new one, and implement the idea I just mentioned. xD;

Thanks for the comments! My banner now is probably the most hard worked piece I've done.

As for the new thread, what if you have an idea sort of like: "If you don't rate the banner above you, yours won't get rated." I'd like that, and if you do post a banner, but do not rate the one above, then the person below should skip yours and rate the one above. Sorry if that sounded confusing. xD

EDIT: Oh yes and, this was one of the only good pictures of Nova I could find and sadly, I had to put it far right because the image cut off there...

EDIT2: Oh and to add on to the new thread idea, how about you must rate the banner above, but you can also rate multiple ones, just thought to put that in.

 

[Momoko]

I'd like to get a rating on this banner...

It didn't take too long..like 15 mins but still..im not hapy with it,it's missing something :/ credit to relyt for helping me rethink my style...

Oh, and, Xeno, i think it's a great idea to do that, we wouldn't be having this problem, but i think that we should also make it so that if somebody doesn't rate the one above,the next one doesn't rate theirs?

 

[RYOUKI]

I wasn't here for a while! :D

Anyways, Here's teh banner I made. Princess Be Careful RAWKS! :D

Err... Rate pls. thx.

 

[Momoko]

It looks good but pretty plain..the txt matches well but the render is a tad bit..huge O.o..anways it's still good so 8/10 :D

 

[Shadez]

so i made a new sig(atleast an attempt to :P )

i'm still working on it so it isn't done yet
but what do you guys think of it ??
tips or rate please (both is even more appreciated)

 

[Comic Tragedy]

Hokay I made this button a while ago and I was wondering what you guys thought of it. BTW E is for El Capitano.

And I made this signature.