Electivire or Magmortar?

[Charizard100]

Who do you like better, Electivire or Magmortar?

 

[AJ™]

There should be an Option for both.

I like Electivire for Physical moves
I like Magmortar for Special moves

 

[Charizard100]

There should be an Option for both.

I like Electivire for Physical moves
I like Magmortar for Special moves

Me too, but in general, who do you like better?

 

[AJ™]

Better looking?
I'd have to go with Electivire.

 

[airconditioning]

Magmortar, since he's not ridiculously overrated. Seriously, why is Electivire even OU?

 

[Gooberdued]

Meh, I don't really use either. I'll go with an Electivire since Magmortar looks *literally* retarded.

 

[YOOM-TAH]

I like em both, but I think I like Electivire a little better. Probably because I like electric types better than fire types.

 

[JKLAZ]

JKLAZ: Neither

Why:
Im serious on this one. Two new evolutions of old guys that both try to look similar to their prevolutions(cool word huh?), but come out looking oddly stupid looking. I dont use either, and i dont like the look of either, so none is my choice

 

[pokemon obssesion101]

i want to battle u next week

i would like to challenge ya to a double battle next wed same time. my friend code is 5197 9767 0667. ok jklaz see ya then

 

[The Hero Without a Name]

'Vire's generally superior as a battler, but a STAB'd Overheat from a modest, max IV'd Magmortar hurts...

 

[Glaceon_]

Electivire is the better looking of the two; I really don't like what they did to Magmar, with its Generation IV evolution. It just looks... really stupid, if I'm honest... =\

 

[hothead]

I loved magma electabuzz magby anf Elekid but these 2 ruined it for me i keep them as magma and electabuzz i dislike them alot

 

[eman1192]

i like electivire, it looks cooler and it has some great moves :)

 

[.]

Electivire is an overrated, underserving-of-OU piece of garbage. Magmotar is an awesome Pokemon and a threat to any team with it's huge, beautiful movepool coupled with a beastly SpA stat.

 

[LethalTexture]

This dicussion would belong better in Pokémon General, I feel.

*moves*

 

[PB.]

I like them both because they are final stages and they both have some really great moves at thier disposal.

 

[InMooseWeTrust]

They both look hideous. Whoever designed them did a horrible job.

 

[Detox]

To be honest....I think they are both ugly(heck, magmortar was ugly as magmar too)and I prefer my Jloteons and Flareons over them any day

 

[Lynnx]

To be honest....I think they are both ugly(heck, magmortar was ugly as magmar too)and I prefer my Jloteons and Flareons over them any day

I agree; I just don't like either design. (I don't like big, bulky Pokemon.) They might be strong, but I really care about looks. =/ So I don't use either of them.

 

[Detox]

Thats why I have my Eveeloutions. Cute and useful.